Thursday, October 18, 2007

Let's Get To The Bottom Of This

Really cool poll here. You take it to find out which presidential candidate you're most in line with. There are obvious problems, of course:

1) Many of the issues they ask about don't fit a simple yes or no. For instance, "Patriot Act"--you may want it changed, but not overturned. "Iran Military Action"--there's the option then there's taking action, and it all depends on what Iran is doing anyway. "Citizen Path For illegals"--what path? Right away, or go to the back of the line?

2) They ask how important each issue is, high, medium or low, but the truth is, for a lot of people, there are just a few issues that truly destermine how they vote.

3) It's possible the pollsters haven't got the candidates positions (which are ever-changing and can even occasionally be nuanced) down right.

4) This sort of thing certainly can't measure how successful the candidates will be at getting the programs passed.

5) The sampling isn't random so the overall results can't tell you too much.

Still, I think in general this poll gives you interesting and even useful information.

So forget the hype, forget the names, forget the media, let's just break it down to what you want and what they claim.

I only wish someone would do a scientific poll to see what the results would be.

4 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

But we don't vote based on who we are most in line with- we vote based on who we like and makes us feel good.

There was a Wall Street Journal question of the day this week (its available by subscription only or I would link) that asked should a candidate's personal life influence a voter's decision. I admired one virulent response that we don't follow rules in a citizenship handbook for deciding who to vote for and he would exercise his right as an American citizen to vote for a candidate based on any reason he damn well chose.

11:03 AM, October 18, 2007  
Blogger LAGuy said...

I agree that we vote more for an image of who the candidate is than anything else. Yet, we tend to feel the one we're voting for is going to be closer to our political beliefs than any other. That's why I found this poll so fascinating; imagine if all you knew about a candidate was where she stood on the issues, no names, no faces, no pr. Suddenly, second and even third-tier candidates have just as much chance as anyone.

12:19 PM, October 18, 2007  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wow -- scary -- I matched Mike Gravel 100%! Is that even possible?

11:11 PM, October 18, 2007  
Blogger LAGuy said...

Gravel is the most popular candidate in the poll. McCain is the least popular. This must mean something, I'm just not sure what.

12:20 AM, October 19, 2007  

Post a Comment

<< Home

web page hit counter