Three For Four
Recently I noticed three Steven Soderbergh films were playing on my cable system at the same time--Traffic (2000), Contagion (2011) and Magic Mike (2012). Odder still, according to my information button, all were four-star films, the highest rating.
Okay, Traffic I can see. It was a solid hit and a highly-regarded film that made a lot of top ten lists. It also won a bunch of Academy Awards, including Best Director for Soderbergh. I'd expect a four-star rating, or at least am not shocked by it.
But Contagion? It was reasonably well-received, and probably made a profit, but is anyone calling it a classic? It's a look at how a serious new epidemic might spread. You might call it a thriller, but Soderbergh keeps his distance, telling the story in a fairly clinical manner. It may have been his intention, but many critics felt it kept the audience at arm's length. Three stars seems about right.
And Magic Mike?! It's a low-budget film about the world of male stripping. It was a surprise hit, and while some critics thought it was better than it had any right to be, it's still a fairly silly work whose main attraction is showing male skin. I can see it as a camp classic, perhaps, but not much more. I would have expected two stars, three tops.
Does Soderbergh have some friends working at my cable company?
2 Comments:
You and your cable company's mother pay attention to their star ranking system
When you turn to the channel you see the stars. It's got at least a subconscious effect.
Post a Comment
<< Home