Happy Xmas (War Is Over)
Jesse has gone back 80 years to 1945.
The Perpetual Three-Dot Column
Here's his top ten films:
1. I Know Where I'm Going!
2. Ivan The Terrible, Part One
3. Scarlet Street
4. Open City
5. Isle Of The Dead
6. Les Dames Du Bois De Boulogne
7. The Spiral Suitcase
8. The Picture Of Dorian Gray
9, Children Of Paradise
10. Detour
I think every one of these is a quality film (even the low budget ones). My only difference is in what order I'd rank them.
Powell and Pressburger are often overrated, but I Know Where I'm Going!, a relatively small, black and white affair, is something special.
I don't love Ivan The Terrible, Part One--it may be my least favorite in the top ten--but it is fun in how it's overdone.
Scarlet Street, The Spiral Staircase and Detour are the three films noir on the list. Bound to have a few in the 40s. All pretty good.
Open City (or Rome, Open City) is one of the top neorealist films. While I question some of the theory behind neorealism, the movement did manage to turn out some decent films.
Isle Of The Dead is part of quite a run of Val Lewton-produced B horror films.
I haven't gotten around to Les Dames Du Bois De Boulogne. I like Bresson's later films, so I suspect I'd like this one.
The Picture Of Dorian Gray is a well-done adaptation of Wilde. (It's more "adapted" than his other work since the source is a novel, not a play.) It helps that Wilde gave them a great visual gimmick to work with.
Children Of Paradise, shot in the middle of the war, may be my favorite film of 1945.
Honorable mentions:
11. Fallen Angel
12. The Body Snatcher
13. My Name Is Julia Ross
14. Draftee Daffy
15. Mildred Pierce
16. Le Vampire
17. Swing Shift Cinderella
18. Wonder Man
19. The Screwy Truant
20. The Wicked Lady
We get yet more noir with Fallen Angel, My Name Is Julia Ross and Mildred Pierce (the last sort of forced into the noir category--the novel had no murder but the film sure does). They hold up about as well as the three in the top ten.
The Body Snatcher is more Val Lewton, and I think I prefer it to Isle Of The Dead.
The Wicked Lady was a big hit in Britain. It's okay, I guess.
Wonder Man is a solid Danny Kaye film for those who like Danny Kaye.
The rest are shorts.
3 Comments:
Okay, here are the films that should be listed but aren't.
The Bells Of St. Mary's
Blithe Spirit
Christmas In Connecticut
Hangover Square
Leave Her To Heaven
Murder He Says
Pride Of The Marines
Spellbound
The Story Of G. I. Joe
They Were Expendable
A Tree Grows In Brooklyn
While I question some of the theory behind neorealism, the movement did manage to turn out some decent films
See also: Dogme 95.
I haven't actually seen that many movies from 1945 but still think my top ten is solid.
1. The Body Snatcher; (best Karloff performance)
2. Hare Tonic;
3. Children of Paradise;
4. Rome: Open City;
5. I Know Where I’m Going;
6. Isle of the Dead;
7. Sugata Sanshiro Part Two;
8. A Diary for Timothy;
9. Detour;
10. Scarlet Street;
Post a Comment
<< Home