Tuesday, August 02, 2011

Science Never Sleeps

Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps is an awful film.  The original Wall Street didn't need a sequel, but if you're going to make one, try to avoid something that's talky, silly and dramatically slack.  But that's not why I want to write about it.

I couldn't help but notice something when I watched it on cable recently.  It starts with Shia LaBeouf's character narrating.  In fact, the writers thought what he says so significant that they repeat it at the end of the film.  It's about evolutionary bubbles being like economic bubbles.  LaBeouf states the mother of all bubbles was the Cambrian Explosion:

Happened around 530 million years ago.  And over the next 70, 80 millions years, the rate of evolution accelerated so fast that we came along.  The human race.

Huh?  First, it's silly to compare the Cambrian Explosion, which took millions of years, to economic bubbles, which come and go quickly. ("Explosion" is perhaps a misleading term.) Second, it is true most major phyla came about during this period, but the human race? Yeah, in a roundabout way, the Cambrian Explosion led to humans, but not until several major extinctions, and quite a few lesser ones, cleared the way for us hundreds of millions of years later.

The writers are stretching way too hard for a useful metaphor.  And they're not done with evolution.  Later LaBeouf is arguing with a co-worker about how to pitch a new energy company at a meeting.  He supports fusion, while she's doubtful:

"They've been saying that fusion is five years away for the past forty years"
"It is.  Laser fusion is the future."
"Oh, can you prove that, boy genius?
"Can you prove evolution, girl genius?  That seems to work though, right?"

Maybe a Wall Street junior exec can't prove evolution, but if Shia would bother to call the biology department of a local college, I'm sure they could satisfy him.

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

They can't even get the business stuff right. Don't expect them to understand biology.

4:48 PM, August 02, 2011  
Blogger QueensGuy said...

Well, if by not provable he means evolution is neither repeatable in a controlled environment, falsifiable, nor able to predict future events, he's got a bit of a point. Or maybe he's just a good Catholic.

7:50 PM, August 02, 2011  
Blogger LAGuy said...

Evolution does makes predictions and because it does, it's also falsifiable. True, it's a huge theory and can't make predictions about everything, but that doesn't mean it's empty. It's also been directly observed, and certain repetitions have been noted.

8:32 PM, August 02, 2011  
Blogger LAGuy said...

It is true, I suppose, at a certain metaphysical level, nothing can be proven. We can be fooled, of course, and so just because we've noted certain things about, say, gravity, and we've been able to predict things with great specificity, it's still possible that we're wrong and have just been very lucky so far. Or just because we built a car, it doesn't mean that magical gremlins who only appear when we close the hood actually make it go. The best we can manage in these cases is Occam's Razor.

But I don't think it's this sort of certitude that the movie is referring to.

8:38 PM, August 02, 2011  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Feh. Occam was a fraud.

3:14 PM, August 03, 2011  

Post a Comment

<< Home

web page hit counter