Monday, January 07, 2008

I Feel Her Pain

Apparently Hillary didn't do very well in the New Hampshire debate. I didn't see it, but I read she came across as angry. I can understand her frustration. She expected a coronation and now it looks like Obama will go 2 for 2.

Of course, it helped that Iowa and New Hampshire allow independent voters, who cut strongly for Obama. Hillary doesn't have a lot of crossover appeal.

The trouble is there's not much she can do. Sure, it was easy enough when her job was to attack Bush--he's unpopular and her voters loved it. It's not so easy to attack Barack. It was better when she could act above the fray, but now she's gotta get down and dirty. This doesn't play that well intra-party, especially against Obama. He's sort of a teflon candidate--he's said foolish things, but they never seem to affect him. And when she goes in for the kill, it turns into a rubber and glue situation.

It was in a debate a couple months ago when Hillary's campaign first started taking on water--she couldn't give a clear answer on driver's licenses for illegal immigrants. This issue doesn't even play well within her own party, much less independents, but she hemmed and hawed since she clearly liked the idea and didn't want to offend Latinos. (That Obama couldn't answer the question well a week later, after all that warning, didn't matter--teflon.) It was the first indication she was vulnerable. And now, in her latest debate, she's flailing.

Adding to her frustration must be that she realizes there aren't any crucial differences between her and Obama, but now his act is playing better than hers. That wasn't part of the game plan.

If she can pull off a victory in New Hampshire, though this is increasingly unlikely, she's back on track. If not, she'll have to go Giuliani and hope that her organizational strengths and general appeal will play well in big Februrary 5th states such as New York and Calfornia. But even as she leads in national polls, once the voters have to concentrate, if she can't show something special, what's to keep them from going with a charming winner?

4 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

... there aren't any crucial differences between her and Obama ...

I think this is why she keeps playing the "experience" card. This is an old slogan, and it's used in every election -- usually by the person who has been in the Senate for a gazillion years and has nothing else in his favor. I don't think the "experience" card has ever won a big election for anybody.

And her use of it is even more problematic, since before 2001 it wasn't exactly her experience!

So I think the reason she's using her "experience" is that it's all she has over him.

I guess she could say, "Obama has been unambiguously against the Iraq war. I have waffled on it, taking whatever line was expedient. Therefore, in January 2009, I would be free to do whatever seems prudent in Iraq -- whereas Obama would be bound by his promises, even if they look foolish in January 2009's hindsight." That would actually be persuasive to me, but obviously she would never say it.

9:04 PM, January 06, 2008  
Blogger New England Guy said...

I believe Obama's appeal goes more than just that he's nice guy and has teflon. Its not just that he's popular- he's popular because he represents a world of potential that seems markedly different from the shrieking partisan idiots.("Experience" has been the experience of poor performance) This happened in 2006 in MAasachusetts in 2006 with the election of Deval Patrick- His line was getting those who had checked out to check back in. Obama seems to resonate a different reasonable approach in an atmosphere in which a widely disparate group of voters think the country is on the wrong track. (George Will says 70% say this but I ve never seen the cite). He's not just a lucky popular guy- he's touched the current nerve among a significant amount.

Whether this means anything in the long run is of course unknown and Governor Patrick has had little success in his first year dealing with the traditional politicians in the legislature (Hillary is trying to sort of make this point with her lines about pretty words)

9:31 AM, January 07, 2008  
Blogger LAGuy said...

I've read your comment twice, New England Guy, and I don't see you saying anything about Obama except the sort of generalities that his supporters use.

12:55 PM, January 07, 2008  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

How does Obama "seems to resonate a different reasonable approach" and Hillary doesn't when Obama is clearly to her left?

1:05 PM, January 07, 2008  

Post a Comment

<< Home

web page hit counter