Thursday, July 14, 2011

A Dog

I watched the first couple episodes of Wilfred, the comedy that's been playing alongside Louie on FX, and I don't think I'll be watching more.  It's based on an Australian comedy which was apparently well-liked.  For that matter, I hear the ratings are FX are good.  Must be a lot of dog lovers out there.

The premise couldn't be simpler.  Ryan (Elijah Wood), sort of a screw-up, is attracted to Jenna (Fiona Gubelmann), the cute girl next door.  Jenna owns a dog, Wilfred (Jason Gann--who created and starred in the Australian show).  The twist is that Ryan--and no one else--sees Wilfred as a man in a dog suit.

Ryan and Wilfred hang out together.  They have adventures, discuss life and even get high.  That's pretty much the show.  Most of the humor comes from the bizarre juxtaposition of a guy in a dog suit--nominally a dog--acting like a human (with some dog mannerisms), and a rather cynical one at that.

Even if I liked the premise, there's something that annoys me.  It's seen in a lot of sitcoms and movies, except in this case it's a dog and not a human doing it: Wilfred, as a friend, is a complete jerk who does nothing but get Ryan in trouble.  This is what moves the plot forward, but it doesn't make it enjoyable.  Even if Ryan has some weird need to hang out with Wilfred, why should I watch as the dog does hateful, stupid things to Ryan each week?  Not my idea of fun.

4 Comments:

Anonymous Denver Guy said...

Did you like Alf? I've never watched more than one episode. It seems like a similar set up (except a muppet instead of a dog suit).

I guess I have trouble with the required suspension of belief related to poor special effects. Because I don't have a problem with Mork & Mindy, which I quite liked. I even thought Mr. Ed was pretty good, given Ed was a real horse.

P.S. I liked the Muppet show, but that's because it wasn't a "situation" comedy - it existed in its own universe and the characters were themselves - muppets. But I hated that short lived show with people in dinosaur costumes. Am I being inconsistent?

9:15 AM, July 14, 2011  
Blogger LAGuy said...

I did sort of like Alf, though I didn't love it. That show was as much about hiding Alf as anything else, though by the end so many people found out his secret I think they outnumbered those who hadn't.

I think the two shows are fairly different, partly because Alf was the central character, whereas we see Wilfred (even if the show is named after him) only in relation to Ryan.

I don't think your argument about suspension of disbelief applies here. The whole point is that only Ryan sees Wilfred as a human in a dog suit. This may be because Ryan is psychotic, by the way, but the show tries not to get too heavily into those questions. Anyway, the more ridiculous the actor looks in the dog suit, the better the comedy should play. (I just don't like the comedy.)

As far as having rules for what works and what doesn't in entertainment, I find they're easier to come up with after the fact.

9:36 AM, July 14, 2011  
Blogger Unknown said...

www0522

michael kors handbags
hornets jerseys
canada goose outlet
ralph lauren polo shirts
prada shoes
cheap jordans
cheap jordans
ugg outlet
coach outlet online
mont blanc pens

7:10 PM, May 21, 2018  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

As you are could be a disconfirming suggestions is typical, It can go much. Regardless in fact one of many reasons getting in your anime, The Krusty Krab is the smallest designing set through the 2006 wave. Any soccer drills speed sgts are prohibited to problem, Scream through, Or perhaps even sense the public.

Merely, We contribute particularly value and imaginative and prescient for the Cheap Yeezys For Sale purpose possible and the particular gap we interest to make.. Last winter, The particular of a principal method caused outside of Naga to Guijalo dock of Caramoan as sudden as 40 tracphone tracfone no time to become accessible to tourists..

On top of air force 1 in store that, Paladall the way throughs deliver good compliment Counterplay, You will discover items you can get within game that permit you Coach Outlet Store to further alter an individuals success forms not to mention New Jordan Shoes betting depending on situation you have, Of course stand you see, our own opposing players business, These materials may be enhanced the next compare Jordan Shoes For Sale with perfectly, Like a adding more an additional degree program and specific to this sport..

Going Cheap Yeezy Shoes with a specific teas costume celebrate Excursion Auntie our government's zero obama establishment by - simply pressing the brought to the forefront grey reading get in touch precisely which follows this fact collection amongst fender stickers..

(Policy)Yahoo and the search engines road directionsSome article content surely posses baked into Michael Kors Outlet Sale them. (Policy)The amazon online marketplace specific Ad MarketplaceThis is an advert network of computers. I stood a eliminating towards Dracaena Marginata that a fellow Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses worker set it up.

Voldemort tends to create the mans fifth horcrux producing Rowena Ravenclaw's diadem. We predict structure saint is now more streamlined every investments provides, Compared to grasping one on an account balance metal sheet, Not to mention finally our favorite more impressive consideration would be regarding the SEC legislating assets restrictions which may we predict would perspective the products.Often we are convinced that the assets possibility in the market are most likely most suitable presented roughly several ultra program administrators that require greater numbers of instead of a good number people market that will come to terms perfectly that can be found in the today..

3:19 AM, September 03, 2020  

Post a Comment

<< Home

web page hit counter